A MINIMALISTIC MANAGEMENT APPROACH FOR THE COMPROMISED ELDERLY PATIENT
Alexandre Mersel, DDS, PhD, Professor*
Director, FDI East Europe Continuing Education Program
Hadar Better, DDS, Specialist Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery
Prof. Alexandre Mersel
34, Ben Yehuda street, 9423001 Jerusalem, Israel
In the last decade we have witnessed a constant increase in the elderly population. The total number of people over 60 is expected to double from 1% to 2% which means from 605 to 2 billion between 2000 -2050 (WHO 2013 a).
The most significant increase will take place in developed countries where the number of the senior citizens will reach 1.7 billion by 2050. To cater to this phenomenon several countries are creating adapted policies in order to deal with the challenge of the “Grey Tsunami” (WHO 1-2013b).The reasons of this trend come as a consequence of several factors.
- better health conditions
- improvement of health services
- broader access to education
- better nutrition in quality and quantity
- creation of psychological support
- broadly promoted oral hygiene
- Better housing conditions with wider possibility for independent or handicapped people.
The treatment of the elderly patient must be specific, because it has to cope
with specific changes in the oral conditions brought about by ageing and also consider the social and psychological aspects. This creates different demands and needs compared with other cohorts. ( 2 ) ***
The general health conditions or medications involved may define the oral rehabilitation ( 3 ). Systemic diseases frequently need special care and prohibit an invasive procedure ( 4 )
The most common diseases and the major causes of mortality are:
heart diseases, cancers, cerebrovascular problems, arteriosclerosis, diabetes, impaired lungs diseases, and neuro-psychological conditions such as Parkinson and Alzheimer.
The Mental status evaluation
During the first examination of the patient and before starting any diagnosis,
prognostic and treatment it is essential to carry out a slight evaluation of the mental status. Dementias are some of the main brain illness with elderly patients.
The practitioner has to realize that the elderly who appear to have dementia suffer from pseudo-senility syndromes and have in fact communication disorders. Therefore, ageism often contributes to the over-diagnosis of dementia.
It is essential to have good knowledge of the cognitive status, namely speech, hearing, and language difficulties and also to know how to evaluate a patient who is suspected of suffering from dementia.
The FROMAJE test is a quick easy mental evaluation test. The FROMAJE–an acronym for Function, Reasoning, Orientation, Memory, Arithmetic, Judgment, and Emotion–Mental Status Guide (FMSG).
Function: Mental function adequate or inadequate.
Reasoning: Understanding test about the ability to explain the meaning of a proverb——–
Orientation: Timing dysfunction
Memory: Distant, recent and immediate memory
Arithmetic: Counting, addition and subtraction
Judgment: Appreciation of cause effect relationship
Emotional state: Patient behavior during the interview.
A total score will give information about the risk to deliver a successful treatment.
Aging is characterized by important changes of the human organs. The conjunction of these changes with age-related pathologies leads to the need of multiple medications in order to maintain their quality of life.
There is a danger when using a great number of drugs as the elderly do, as that could also result in undesirable side effects.
Mouth dryness or Xerostomia is one of the common phenomena.
Xerostomia has numerous consequences which affect eating, swallowing, and taste reduction, thus impairing the nutritional status.
The diminution of the saliva flow will result in the poor retention of the removable prosthesis and a burning mouth pain. ( 5 )
Symptoms such as a burning mouth, dry lips and altered speech and an ulcerated mucosa are the consequences of hypo salivation and xerostomia.
It has been estimated that actually about 30% of the elderly suffer from hypo salivation and xerostomia ( 6 )
TASTE ALTERATION, mouth dryness and teeth staining are often side effects of the medication taken by the elderly. A survey in Helsinki demonstrates there is a relationship between the drug intake and xerostomia; that the great the number of medication, the greater the probability of mouth dryness.
Taste reduction influences dietetic habits with an important consumption of salt or sugar.
Oral Cancer has high morbidity and mortality ( 7). Commonly the 5year survival rate is 75 % for local lesions, but in the case of lesions with distant metastasis only 17%. The direct causes are; tobacco, alcohol, infections, and chronic irritation due to very sharp teeth or prosthesis.
The indirect causes are nutritional deficiencies, poor oral awareness, and poor access to oral care for prevention and early detection.
Oral diseases are frequent and there is a need for an integrative approach concerning the understanding and management of the oral conditions paying particular attention to systemic implications ( 8 )J. Oral Diseases
Oral & Dental diseases).
Dental findings in diabetic adults.
Diabetes mellitus is a major threat to global health, and is the fourth leading
cause of death by disease .As it is a systemic disease, diabetic elderly patients may be affected both with respect to the quality and length of their life. Several studies reported a higher prevalence of caries, and especially root caries.
Also the periodontium is severely affected and lead to the loss of even intact teeth.
One of the most silent hosts is Candida, which affects a great number of elderly mainly in the oral cavity and also in the removable prosthesis.
It has been mentioned that one of the main mortality reasons with the elderly
is the Candida infection: oral candidiasis is a sign of impaired local or systemic defense mechanism. The carriage rate of Candida depends of the age and health of the patient. In a study of the elderly in Japan, Candida was detected in 67% of the patients. Candida is the fourth most common cause of hospital bloodstream infections in the US .( 9 )
The ability of Candida to adhere to the mucosa and the dentures plays an important role in the pathogenesis.
With respect to complete dentures, the disappearance of Complete Denture Prosthodontics has been predicted.(10)
Nevertheless the need for complete dentures remains essential for a large number of the aged patients especially in the cohort of the “old-old”.
Obviously the transition from a partial to full dentures has shifted to a higher age. [70-80]
In Switzerland 85.9 % of persons aged 85 or above report wearing a removable prosthesis and amongst them 37.2 % are totally edentulous.
In the United States, the prediction is that there will be 37.9 million elderly by 2020, aged 70-80. Therefore, if complete dentures will be eliminated from the standard dental education curriculum, the result will be that millions of patients will be forced to find out alternative providers of their prosthesis.
Complete Denture remains a difficult oral rehabilitation because it needs to challenge important physiological and psychological problems.
Since ageing is not a pathology but a permanent decrease of the individual faculties, a practitioner should face the implications of ageing in the oral cavity. Genetic and biologic factors as well as social and behavioral issues may play an important role.
The necessity of a bio-ethic attempt
Despite the fact that the dentist applies the rules he was taught, he is very disappointed with the results. Unfortunately there are dogmas which dragged down to pitfall the prosthetic restoration for senior patients.
Since geriatric dentistry is not a priority in the basic educational syllabus, the profession is not able to face a growing minority of atypical or unusual persons looking for prosthodontic treatment that present outstanding features or variations from the normality. Therefore, these handicapped patients described as “denture cripples” cannot receive conventional treatment or often cannot wear the dentures as completed by the dentists.( 11)
The classical approach is devoted to the treatment of typical or normal
patients, but for the old-old or atypical patients special diagnostic and
solutions are recommended.
A typical or conventional patient can be categorized as the one evincing
the following characteristics:
- A patient who comes to the dental office for prosthodontic treatment after losing or about to lose his natural teeth.
- His expectation with respect to the dental care is to be provided with a set of removable dentures which will partly replace the functions fulfilled by his natural teeth.
- He is agreeable to the treatment and collaborates with the dentist during the clinical procedures and the necessary adjustments that follow the delivery of the dentures.
- He does not present any severe systemic or physical limitations for the treatment and for the self- home care.
- The masticatory muscles and the tempura-mandibular joints are reasonably healthy without functional limitations.
- The residual ridged and their adjacent structures are of normal size and form, and able to provide a stable functional foundation of the dentures.
- The soft and hard oral tissues are healthy and properly lubricated by the salivary flow.
- The tongue and the tongue attachments are of normal size and position that allows the insertion and proper function of the mandibular prosthesis.
- There is a minimal or non-existing Gagging reflex at the posterior region of the maxillary during the treatment and after upper denture insertion.
- At a physiological vertical dimension at occlusion there is enough adequate denture space for the construction of the denture base and the artificial teeth.
- The special occlusal relations between the edentulous ridges do permit setting of the artificial teeth on the top or close to the residual crests and allows harmonious arrangements.
- The patient shows a reasonable and positive attitude acceptance and adaptation ability following the delivery dentures
- Last but not least; there are NO symmetric patients as educated in the conventional Text-books. Since the left and right side are not symmetric, that means that the teeth arrangement do not respect the patient physiology
To conclude, with the ageing there is no ideal patient that presents all the described criteria.
- Physiological design in Complete Dentures ( article 12 )
Here are the most frequent features.
Most patients present one or two systemic diseases. The most common are hypertension, cardio-vascular and diabetes problems
Moreover, there are also neurological systemic critical situations such as Parkinson, Alzheimer and different kinds of depression. Different forms of cancer are also frequent.
One of the most difficult obstacles for a successful treatment is frequent psycho-geriatrics attitudes and behavioral disorders.( 13 )
Besides the classic organic brain syndromes there are also paranoid
states and affective disorders
These factors will hardly compromise the treatment planning.
With the increase in life span and the difficulties of the economic situation there appears an economic gap and consequently a drop in the financial means.
4- Physiology evolution with Aging;
There is a change of the elderly patient physiology with ageing – change in the supporting structures, muscles and the natural or acquired reflexes.
Particular attention was attached to the study of bone resorption, the important differences between the maxillary and the mandible. A growing difference has been noted between the right and the left side.
Nevertheless very few studies were found on the fundamental asymmetry
of the great majority of the individuals.
Usually one side is shorter than the other one. Often the middle of the maxillary does not correspond to the middle of the face.
This is in total contradiction with was thought in most text-books.
In the same way the condylar guidance is different between the two sides providing an unequal occlusal climatic. In general the ridge resorption is centripetal in the maxillary and centrifugal in the mandible causing in this way a cross –bite problematic situation.
A lot of research pointed out the asymmetry of the chewing cycles, inducing in this way a special occlusal balance system.
Another important fact is the acquired para-function by poor prosthetic restorations and creating serious obstacle for the stability of the new dentures. Anyway when considering an adapted treatment planning for the old-old patient, this asymmetric factor must be taken under consideration.
Satisfaction with Complete dentures:
In the cohort of elderly there is an important group who constantly has great difficulty in adjusting and wearing dentures. Therefore they have a low quality of life and are dissatisfied to cause considerable problems to the dentists. Identifying these patients prior the treatment will give the practitioner the possibility to modify the approach and to help the patient
to adopt more realistic expectations. There is a great variety of factors involved in the dissatisfaction.( 14 )
- Past denture experience is more related to denture satisfaction that the age.
- Comfort is a decisive factor, because the patient keeps comparing the new dentures to the old ones, in terms of the design of the dentures, the occlusal system, the free-way space and phonetics.
- Usually the criteria for conventional dentures are: accepted esthetics, good retention and stability, the ability to chew properly, and acceptable phonetics .A failure in one of these conditions will led to a pitfall of all the oral
- Switching roughly from an old denture to a new one is often a reason of destabilization for the geriatric patient. In this situation the patient will never accept the new restoration.
- This underlines the importance of the psychological aspects in the treatment of the elderly In the same way the influence of the systemic condition and medication have an impact on the tolerance of dentures.
- Only a step by step treatment plan, with evaluation possibilities is recommended. These transitional steps are the condition sine qua non
for comprehensive and tolerated changes.
The description above brings a specific approach to the elderly/frail
patient. It is a fact that ageing is a process which absolutely affects the patients differently. Chronological age is not the only indicator of the geriatric status. There is tremendous variability in the biological and psychological aspects between the patients. Consequently there should be
an individual and specific approach for each individual. The treatment of these patients asks for a realistic risk-benefit evaluation. One of the most important challenges is adapted management.
To avoid useless stress situations and important economic burden, it is recommended to proceed by a step by step schedule so as to be able to do a constant revaluation. It requests first palliative treatment and then transitional or intermediary restorations.
When considering the permanent or final stage it should be essential to act in a preventive perspective, giving always a possibility for a repair or a transformation of the Prosthetic devices. To summarize this non-conventional approach ; the Minimal Invasive Management is highly recommended.
1. Bourgeois D, Nihtila A, Mersel A. Prevalence of caries and edentulousness among 65-74-year-olds in Europe. Bull World Health Organ. 1998;76(4):413-417.
2. Knickman JR, Snell EK. The 2030 problem: caring for aging baby boomers. Health Serv Res. 2002;37(4):849-884.Health Serv Res. 2002 Aug;37(4):849-84. The 2030 problem: caring for aging baby boomers. Knickman JR1, Snell EK.
3. Pandey A, Pandey M, Siddique S, Malik SN, Alam MK. Gerodontics: A Boon for the Oral Health of Geriatric Patient. International Medical Journal. 2014; 21(3):328-330.
4. Müller F, Naharro M, Carlsson GE. What are the prevalence and incidence of tooth loss in the adult and elderly population in Europe? Clinic Oral Implants Res. 2007;18 Suppl 3:2-14.
5. de Deco CP, Reis MRVS, da Silva Marchini AMP, da Rocha RF, dos Santos MBF, Marchini L. Taste alteration , mouth dryness and teeth staining as side effects of medications taken by elderly. Braz. J. Oral Sciences. 2014;13(4):257-260.
6. Naseem Shah. Oral and Dental diseases. NCMH Background Papers .:Burden of Disease in India. 2014,275-297 Shah N. Oral and Dental diseases: Causes, prevention and treatment strategies. In: NCMH Background Papers—Burden of Disease in India, New Delhi: Shree Om Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.; 2005, 275-298.
7. Scully C, Sciubba JJ, Bagan JV. Oral mucosal precancer and cancer: A helpful discriminating clinical tool. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal. 2015;20(5):e587-90.
8. Chen X, Chen H, Douglas C, Preiser JS, Shuman SK. Dental treatment intensity in frail older adults in the last year of life. J Am Dent Assoc. 2013;144(11):1234-1242.
9. Wang J, Ohshima T, Yasunari U, Namikoshi S, Yoshihara A, Miyazaki H, Maeda N. The carriage of Candida species on the dorsal surface of the tongue: the correlation with the dental, periodontal and prosthetic status in elderly subjects. Gerodontology. 2006;23(3):157-163.
10. Douglass CW, Shih A, Ostry L. Will there be a need for complete dentures in the United States in 2020? J Prosthet Dent. 2002;87(1):5-8.
11..Mersel A. Atypical Edentulous Patients: a Gerodontic approach.J.Dental Asia . 2007 ,3-4 ; 31-3333. Dental Asia. 2007; March/April:31-33.
12. Mersel AS, Eisenberg G. Physiological design of the complete denture space. J. Dental Asia . 2012 ,November/December: 24-28.
13.L.Marchini . Patient’s satisfaction with complete dentures : an update.J. Brazilian Sciences. 2014 ,10-1; 5-17.
14. Braz Dent Sci. 2014;17(4): 5-16.14. Vered Y, Zadik D, Mersel A. [The influence of socio-demographic and psychological variables on the level of satisfaction of geriatric patients from dental care]. Refuat Hapeh Vehashinayim (1993). 2002;19(3):58-61, 90.